Someone posted a message on a bulletin board asking anyone to explain the appeal of fixed gear bikes. The following is my response (slightly edited):
Fixed gear bikes are not for everyone, they are for people who want to experience being one with the bicycle, it’s a very pure form of riding. It is one of those things that has to be experienced to be understood.
I rode bikes regularly for several years before trying one. At first it was scary but as I got used to it, I came to prefer it. I ended up selling all my other bikes.
The fixed gear bike is elegant in its simplicity. There are no extra bits on it to distract from pure and simple riding; it is basically two wheels, a frame, pedals, chain, cogs, a seat and handlebars; nothing more (I added a front brake for emergency stops).
I liked it because there are fewer things to break, so maintenance is quick and simple. I called my fixie my Maintenance Free Bike. I also found that the flywheel effect of the pedals moving with the drive train made it easier to ride in strong headwinds. I also had an incredible amount of control due to being directly connected to the back wheel.
There is also the challenge of learning to ride a fixie well. The goal is not speed as much as it is grace and flow. One challenge I had was to make a trip across town without putting my foot down. I learned how to anticipate traffic, how to slow down for an intersection, and how to anticipate the changing of the traffic lights. I became more aware of my surroundings and I even felt safer on my fixie.
I recently sold my fixie, and I am currently riding an old English 3 speed (built like a tank and ugly). I will probably get another fixie before the year is over because I am starting to miss it already, but it was a little hard on the knees. Writing this makes me want to get another one!
Some people ride fixies to be a part of a crowd, kind of an elitist thing for some, but I rode one because I like simplicity.